Catch-a-Fire Pizza Voted Best Overall Pizza in Cincinnati 2022 by CityBeat

CityBeat readers and publication staff have voted Catch-a-Fire Pizza as the Best Of Cincinnati® again in 2022! We are honored to serve you, your families, and our communities the best wood-fired pizza in Cincinnati. Thank you for celebrating your birthdays, date nights, anniversaries, and family events every week at our Oakley location within MadTree, as well as our stand alone restaurant, bar, and bottle shop in Blue Ash. You are the reason we continue to be voted the best, and you are the reason we are now opening another location in Lebanon this Fall.


And a big #SHOUTOUT to our amazing work Family. They take pride every day in crafting our wood-fired cuisine to make sure it is fresh, creative & delicious! They consistently have positive attitudes, maintain strong moral and ethical principles, use skillful chef-driven techniques, and are truly passionate for our craft. We are thankful to have a well-connected team that creates an unparalleled experience for our guests. Bravo!


Finally, we’d like to thank and recognize our sustainable/local partners who work with us to make our wood-fired pizza the best. We know that we stand out in Cincinnati because of our fresh and local partners. Thank you MadTree, 80 Acres Farms, Tuba Baking Company, Smoking Goose, Glier's Goetta, Urban Stead Cheese, The BE Hive, Crazy Acres Market Farm, Free bird chicken, Running Creek Farm, and the Shroomery for making us the best wood-fired pizza in Cincinnati year after year.

BEST OVERALL PIZZA (NON-CHAIN)

  1. Taglio

  2. Adriatico’s

  3. Two Cities Pizza Co.

  4. Strong’s Brick Oven Pizzeria

  5. Krimmer’s Italianette Pizzeria

  6. Fireside Pizza

  7. Trotta’s Pizza & Drive-Thru

  8. Saint Francis Apizza

  9. Catch-a-Fire Pizza

  10. Joe’s Pizza Napoli